While Neesee looks forward to her and Robert's college reunion so she can meet a good man, Robert dreads the event because his rival, Fitz (Brooklyn McLinn), who once tripped him and won a basketball game, will be there. Meanwhile, Robert discovers that he still has a crush on his older professor and is excited that she finds him attractive too--but an encounter with the sexually energetic woman leaves him unable to compete well against Fitz in a rematch.