It's time for Joe Maddalena's annual Appraisal Fair. Joe and his team set up shop at the Screen Actors Guild to meet with the public, who will bring them their props and Hollywood memorabilia items for review. Before the team heads out the door, Tracey McCall tells them she's following her own leads instead of going to the fair. Jon Mankuta and prop expert Jesse D'Angelo are skeptical, but Joe proposes a challenge: whoever brings him the best item wins a trip to Hawaii. The hunt is on. At the Appraisal Fair, Jon and Jesse scour the crowd for great items to bring to Joe. Jon scores early with a rare Sheena, Queen of the Jungle costume. Jesse finds a Men in Black piece, but the owner won't consign. Meanwhile, Tracey searches the racks at Roxy Deluxe, a massive costume rental house. She finds Jeff Bridges' Dude sweater from The Big Lebowski. Will it be enough to beat Jon and Jesse? A Hawaiian vacation is on the line, and it all comes down to the auction.