Joe Maddalena's mom, Betty, a retired antiques dealer, surprises Joe when she drops in on him with a lead. A Christmas museum in Ohio has had to close its doors and needs to raise enough money to reopen in a permanent location. Joe and Tracey McCall jump at the chance to help this quirky museum reopen. Upon their arrival, Joe can't believe his eyes. The museum's owner not only has rosy cheeks and a round little belly, his actual name is Mark Klaus. Meanwhile, Brian Chanes and Jon Mankuta pay a visit to Brian's old pal at Make-up and Monsters. After his return from Ohio, Joe pays a visit to the son of the late Olan Chiles. Olan was a collector of anything and everything.