Jeannie is chosen Queen of the Supermarkets for being the millionth customer at Food City. Meanwhile, Tony brushes off Dr. Bellows' request that he be Honorary Grand Marshall of the Cocoa Beach Rodeo because he's afraid of horses. Alarmed that Jeannie's being Queen might expose their relationship, Tony orders her to stay away from Food City. Charlie Akins, the Rodeo Manager, and Wild Bill Barrows, a rider, followed by Roger and the Food City manager, come to Tony's house to see Jeannie. If Wild Bill comes out top rider, he wins a date with Jeannie, with other prizes. Tony orders her to refrain from magic to stop Wild Bill from winning, to avoid arousing suspicion. Tony and Roger go to the Rodeo in cowboy regalia. They accidentally sign entry blanks and are terrified by the Brahma bulls. Tony sends Roger for Jeannie to rescue them. Roger can't find Jeannie and Tony ends up being roped by a calf. Trying to escape, he goes through the wrong gate and lands on a bucking bronco. As Tony desperately hangs on, Roger finally reaches Jeannie. She blinks, not only saving Tony but making him beat out Wild Bill. When Dr. Bellows accuses Tony of misleading him that he knew nothing about horses, Tony replies that he does know something about women.