Upon finding that the newsstand where they first met has burned down, Paul and Jamie realize they've been transported back in time. Agreeing to meet up in an hour, Paul sets off for the address on his driver's license and finds that he's living with Ira. Meanwhile, Jamie discovers that she's a partner in her own P.R. firm with an overweight and neurotic Fran as her assistant. And when she expresses a good deal of surprise at his arrival, Jamie's old boyfriend Alan decides she must be seeing someone else and breaks up with her on the spot. Realizing there isn't anyone else, Jamie settles into her job and her new persona as she moves in with Lisa. Meanwhile, with Paul staying at home with Murray, Ira heads off for his date for the evening a new woman he just met .... Jamie! As Ira is getting to know more about her, Paul has second thoughts and shows up at the club where Susannah approaches him. And it's when Ira comes to the bar to get Jamie a drink that things get interesting. After accidentally bumping into Susannah, Ira learns that her band is in need of a new keyboard player. And seeing that she's with Paul, Ira asks him to keep Jamie busy for a few minutes. But when Paul says he's going back home, Ira placates Jamie before joining Susannah's band on stage. After sending Jamie on her way, Ira then sets off to meet Susannah for breakfast. Meanwhile, unable to sleep, Jamie goes out for a newspaper, as does Paul. And, after wandering from newsstand to newsstand in search of something to satisfy them, they finally run into each other before being transported back into their real lives once and for all.