As Dave is being grilled by the FBI as to Jimmy's whereabouts, Johnny Johnson continues endearing himself to the rest of the station's staff. Recognizing his evil intentions, Dave asks Lisa for help, only to find that she, too, has fallen under Johnny's spell. Meanwhile, a phone call reveals that Jimmy is hiding at Dave's boyhood home in Wisconsin. And when Jimmy orders Dave to get the green duffel bag that could implicate him in he D.B. Cooper hijacking, Lisa insists on using her seductive ways to get it. While Dave has his doubts, he has no choice but to accept her offer. But instead of getting the bag, Lisa is stunned when Johnny asks her to get married. Despite knowing that he's evil, Lisa cannot decide what to do about Johnny's proposal. As everyone else urges her to accept, Dave turns to Johnny to warn him to keep away from Lisa. Meanwhile, Johnny sends Matthew in an assignment to find Jimmy. When Johnny offers to turn over the duffel bag to him if only Lisa will accept his proposal, Dave sets out to get her to agree to the marriage. However, after Dave admits to hoping they would one day get back together, Lisa is't so sure about what to do. With Jimmy and Matthew holed up in Dave's childhood bedroom, Lisa decides to turn down Johnny's proposal. As a result, Johnny gets revenge by giving the bag to Dave before calling the FBI and getting him blamed for Jimmy and Matthew's subsequent arrest.