Ned, Chuck and Emerson search for a missing teen, Nikki Heaps (guest star HAYLEY McFARLAND - Gilmore Girls, ER), who has run off to the circus … a circus where people keep turning up dead. Meanwhile, overcome with guilt, Lily pays Olive a visit at the nunnery. Recurring guest star DIANA SCARWID (Wonderfalls, Truman What Lies Beneath) appears as Mother Superior.
