Eddie (Brad Garrett) thinks he's off the hook when Joy (Joely Fisher) decides they should sit this anniversary out. But when she gives him a sentimental present, Eddie scrambles to find a way to outdo her. Vowing to take Joy on her lifelong dream snorkleing trip, Eddie sets out to learn how to swim with the assistance of self-proclaimedBlack Dolphin - a.k.a. Kenny (J.B. Smoove). Yet before long, he is forced to salvage romance in a different way when his plan drowns.