Bellamy is alarmed when he spots Caleb talking to Jacob.
Dr. Eric Ward, Maggie's friend from the NIH, arrives in Arcadia and shares a theory with Agent Bellamy and Maggie. Can he predict when and where future returns may happen?
Bellamy and Maggie go in search of answers.
Lucille confides her fears in Maggie.
After a fight breaks out in Tom's church, he pleads with his congregation not to let what's happening in Arcadia divide them. But before any progress can be made, the church learns Tom's secret: Rachael is back and pregnant with his child.
Bellamy races to tell the Langstons about Caleb's disappearance.
Bellamy is having a conversation with Maggie about her future and his past when he notices something in the road. He's stunned when he sees that it's Rachael, especially considering he had just watched her die again.
Now that Fred is conspiring against all of those who have returned to Arcadia, Jacob is in danger. Lucille and Fred think the only way their son can remain safe is if Bellamy takes him far from town.
Watch as Maggie gives Rachael the shocking news.
When Jacob disappears, Lucille and Henry are frantic. Turns out, he has run away. They find him at the park where he's helping another family who he claims is just like him.
Maggie's reunion with her mother doesn't quite go as planned. She discovers that Barbara has been back a week! A heartbroken Maggie confronts Barbara about the past, then demands she tell Fred she's returned.
When things take an even more shocking turn, Maggie's life-long friend, Elaine Richards, finds herself drawn into Arcadia's growing mystery. Bellamy, an outsider in the town, joins forces with Maggie to figure out why the unexplainable is happening in Arcadia.
Sheriff Fred and Agent Bellamy watch as Elaine visits her father.
A troubled Fred confronts Maggie and Bellamy.
Download the TV Guide app for iPhone, iPad and Android!