Sue holds a seance with her friends.
As Halloween approaches, Sue holds a séance during a sleepover with her fellow Wrestlerettes and swears that she's seen the ghost of Christopher Columbus and one of his ships; Axl finds himself being hazed by the football team and not allowed to enter his own Halloween party that's being thrown in his dorm room; and the family tries in vain to give Brick advice on how to ask out a girl he likes to go with him to a Halloween dance.
As Halloween approaches, Sue holds a séance with her Wrestlerettes; Axl is hazed by the football team and not allowed to his own party; and Brick tries to ask a girl to the dance.
As Oz (Christian Slater) squares off in a fight to the finish with his longtime nemesis Henry Shaw (guest star Samm Levine), Cameron’s (Bret Harrison) marriage to Molly (Erin Richards) is threatened by the unexpected return of his ex-girlfriend and Contra’s lock-picking expert, Melanie (Odette Annable).
When his priceless Chewbacca costume from Star Wars is stolen, Molly’s (Erin Richards) uncle Peter Mayhew turns to Contra to get it back. And though Oz (Christian Slater) plans to use the hefty reward to buy his company back from OCP, he still finds himself relying on Veronica (Megan Mullally) for help.
As Veronica (Megan Mullally) dupes Cameron (Bret Harrison) into being her date for a wedding, Oz (Christian Slater) plots to help Cash (Alphonso McAuley) land a date with Molly (Erin Richards).
Veronica (Megan Mullally) believes her career is in jeopardy when longtime corporate rival Heather O’Brien (guest star Perrey Reeves) decides to give Contra a makeover. Hoping to woo Heather’s lovely assistant, Cameron (Bret Harrison) tries to make his phony green card marriage to Molly (Erin Richards) appear legitimate.
When her visa expires, Molly’s (Erin Richards) imminent deportation leads her into a sham marriage with Cameron (Bret Harrison). Meanwhile, Oz (Christian Slater) discovers that he is still married to his ex-wife Amy (guest star Alyssa Milano).
After she’s banned from Contra’s boys’ night out, Veronica (Megan Mullally) rallies the women for their own night on the town. But as Cameron (Bret Harrison) worries about being the subject of the girls’ gossip, the disappearance of a prized trophy forces Contra’s men and women to join forces to find it.
As Veronica (Megan Mullally) moves to take over Contra, Oz (Christian Slater) resists her efforts to transform the company into a bland corporate subsidiary as he tries to retain the loyalty of his staff.