As tensions between Elijah and Hayley grow, Klaus steps in and encourages her to regain her position within her werewolf pack. Still under Davina's control, Mikael (recurring guest star Sebastian Roché) grows impatient while she attempts to uncover a spell that would protect those closest to her. When Elijah turns to Marcel for help in tracking down a vital piece of information, he is forced to remember a time long ago when they were on better terms. Meanwhile, Davina and Kaleb (recurring guest star Daniel Sharman) find themselves in a dangerous situation when unexpected visitors show up and crash their dinner. Finally, Klaus grows suspicious after a meeting with Cassie (recurring guest star Natalie Dreyfuss – The Secret Life of the American Teenager) doesn't go as he had planned. Nathaniel Buzolic (Out of the Blue) appears in flashbacks to the 1700s.