An eccentric police consultant is brought into the SBPD to interview Shawn, Gus, Lassiter and Juliet about their seemingly poor police work on a tough case.
After a woman dies from what appears to be a plastic surgery mishap, Shawn and Gus believe the killer is her doctor, a woman who happens to be an old flame of Henry's.
After Shawn and Gus' favorite radio DJ is murdered, they go undercover as on-air personalities to find his killer.
After Gus accidentally tampers with the crime where his boss was killed, Shawn helps him find the real murderer before Gus is arrested.
After the Mayor dies in what appears to be a surfing accident, Shawn investigates and ends up running for mayor himself.
Shawn bonds with Woody, and Juliet befriends a girl who Shawn believes to be a killer.
Shawn solves a case involving a mysterious Swedish woman and imagines how the same case would have been solved had he done one thing differently.
The gang spends the weekend at a casino resort for a wedding and crosses paths with a local crime boss whose presence jeopardizes the impending nuptials.
After Gus is tasked with taking care of his girlfriend's son Maximus for the day, he jeopardizes their relationship when an innocent trip to the circus turns deadly.
Shawn and Gus attend a party hosted by an aging rockstar named Billy Lipps, a man the SBPD arrested years ago for a murder he doesn't remember committing.
Shawn attempts to bond with Juliet's stepfather Lloyd, a seemingly harmless accountant.
Shawn and Gus join a pair of college students in the woods who are filming a documentary on Bigfoot.
Gus gets a girlfriend, and Juliet goes undercover on an online dating site to catch a killer while Shawn tries to holster his jealousy.
After Henry takes a bullet to the chest and is rushed to the hospital, a spiteful Shawn seeks revenge on the shooter and everyone else involved in the scandal.
Shawn discovers a body that's connected to an unsolved case his father was investigating 20 years earlier.
After a chef wrongly accused of armed robbery is exonerated, he hires Shawn and Gus to find the real culprit.
Lassie performs "Superfreak."
Shawn and Gus discuss the finer points of the burrito.
Writer commentary with Andy Berman
Episode commentary with James Roday and Andy Berman
Bloopers from "Murder Anyone?"
Lassiter sings "Private Eyes"
What would Al B. Sure say? Night and Day!
Song parody with Tim Omundson and Andy Berman
Lil' Shawn and Gus attends their Pre-school reunion.
Shawn & Gus are bringing a little Hall & Oates flavor with them to Wednesdays...
When Shawn and Gus join Gus' new girlfriend on a rafting trip, a member of the group goes overboard, but Shawn quickly realizes it was no accident.
Terence Trent D'arby's "Wishing Well"
"Maneater" by Hall & Oates
Commentary with Steve Franks & Tim Meltreger